Detecting the outer foil of a non-polarized cap

[dbishopbliss]

I've been hanging out in the guitar forums lately and I came across a post where someone was asking how to detect the outer foil of a cap.  I always thought that non-polarized caps weren't really directional and never gave much thought to it.  However, this video has made me realize that there may be benefits.  Subsequently, another poster added this comment:

The proper way to connect the outside foil is to the low impedance side of the circuit, which, in the case of coupling caps, will normally be the plate of the previous stage. If it is a bypass cap to ground, connect the outside foil to the grounded side. If it is a bypass cap from a signal to B+, connect the outside foil to B+. The outside foil will act as a shield against electric field coupling into the capacitor, so you want it to have the lowest impedance return path to ground.

Has anyone here considered this?  I've just never heard it mentioned before except when asking about the leads of auricaps in the Foreplay.

[porcupunctis]

I have heard about this before but hadn't given it too much thought.  I remember reading that some of the polys are marked.  I just bought a couple of 100uf Solens for my Crack and I didn't see anything that would look like obvious markings to me.  My guess it that you would have to email the manufacturer to know for certain.

Thinking out loud made me go get the Solens and examine them again.  One lead is longer but there is no indication of what that means.  Just downloaded the PDF from the Solens site and that didn't help either.  I will send an email and see what they say.

[Grainger49]

For some reason I only hear this when someone is using the Auricaps.  Maybe because the manufacturer clearly states how to wire the caps.

Here is the link:

http://www.audience-av.com/capacitors/a_applications.php

I don't have a guitar amp to test with and the audio was such that I didn't understand his explanation anyway.  But I do have a scope and I really followed that one.

Edit:

So I don't have to wait for the video to load again the oscilloscope method is to clip the ground and signal leads of one channel to the cap leads.  Put an AC cord that is being used against the body of the cap.  Read the scope, then swap the scope probe leads.  Whichever orientation has the lower impressed voltage on it the ground lead is on the outer foil.

[dbishopbliss]

Even though the guitar amp method is a little tough to follow, you can easily hear that there is more noise when the cap is oriented one way versus other.  Next time I build an amp (actually I'm restoring a guitar amp now), I will be marking the outer foil end on my caps and installing them as described.  It would be interesting to compare the two in an audio circuit.

[jrebman]

Usually, the shorter lead is the foil side, which you also want to try to get as close physically to the lowest impedance point.  Generallly the foil is also related to the direction of the writing on the cap, but it's early, and I'm somewhat confused on what the rule about this is, so I won't even guess as to which end the writing goes to.

HTH,

Jim

[Paul Joppa]

The writing is known to go in both directions, sometimes even on different models from the same company!

You can test it. Put some AC across the capacitor, and wrap a bit of foil or copper tape around the cap. Then measure voltage from each lead to the foil - no voltage = outer foil, some voltage = inner foil.

[jrebman]

No wonder it confuses me :-).  How can you remember a rule when there is no rule?

-- Jim

[VoltSecond]

Some manufactures will mark a transformer's (or inductors) DOT with whether it should go to AC ground or AC hot.  I haven’t seen a standard for this. On some transformers and inductors it actually makes a difference.

[Grainger49]

   .  .  .   You can test it. Put some AC across the capacitor, and wrap a bit of foil or copper tape around the cap. Then measure voltage from each lead to the foil - no voltage = outer foil, some voltage = inner foil.

I love it.  I'm a pragmatic person.  So the oscilloscope and ac across the cap with foil on the outside makes a lot of sense to me.  This is what I will be doing in the future.

Thanks to David and Paul for the good "how to."

[ssssly]

Could always just hack one open.

[porcupunctis]

I got an answer from Solen about how they mark their caps.  According to Chris, the longer lead is connected to the outer foil and should be connected to the negative side or ground.

Keep in mind that this may not be a universal standard across manufacturers. 

[jrebman]

Ok, so the bottom line here is... there is no standard, or if there is, compliance is voluntary :-).

-- Jim