Doc is encouraging you to determine if the gain of system is so high that you need to pad the input of your amp.
Interestingly I am using my old pair of proper ladder stepped attenuators from my FP2 (which are a *much* higher resistance) as varying the input inpedance depending on volume is something I prefer not to do...
Paul Joppa goes through preamp gain, amp gain, speaker sensitivity etc. to explain why some guys hear a dead silent preamp and others are listening to tube rush and the noise floor.
It is a good idea to read it all, not in one sitting but maybe in installments. But you can jump down to " adjusting the amplifier/speaker sensitivity" which is probably the crux of your problem. Just guessing.
The speakers are 88Db/W and the power amps are 90W PP845s so there may be some milage in this...
A search of the forum will show that you are not alone, and the problem has always been fixed. Hang in there.
Please be aware that the noise floor is very very much below where my heavily upgraded Foreplay2 was!
Right now the sound is very "sat on" <-- this I suspect is because the output coupling capactors need to be burnt in...