. . . Also in between checking here for updates, I connected the preamp to the amp and cdp, took a deep breath and flipped the switch... and after turning the selector switch there was music (Cannonball Adderley). But only had it powered for a few minutes due to the high volume. I'm confused by the double volume control though - I don't think I have these correct as they are working like a selector switch - the volume increments are hugh in decible levels. . . .
John,
This sounds like it plays, but loudly. If it is the wrong volume level then there might be a wiring swap in the Sweetest Whispers (SW). Take a look at the picture of the completed FP III in the manual, page 35. If your wiring is right then the resistors in each step are possibly out of whack. Another possibility is you need a bigger series resistor for your CDP. Check page 24 of the manual. It explains how to choose the resistors (supplied by BH) you would want to use as replacements.
Somewhere PJ has posted explaining how many additional steps on the SW each resistor will give you to reach the same volume level you have with the stock resistors. That will help you select the right ones too.