Man, there's one thing I hate about this forum software. Grainger posted while I was composing my response, so my post did not go through - and the warning is in small print, orange on black and I never see it. I'll try again:
Sounds like you have an equalization error, or a tape head loading error. There were a few versions of the tape head modification to the Seduction, and I don't recall if you said anything in the other thread about what version you have.
(They are documented at
http://www.bottlehead.com/et/adobespc/Seduction/bottleheadtapeheadpreamp.htm in case anyone needs the link.)
The earliest versiuon had trimpots for the HF equalization (adjusts the 5-10kHz level)) and for the tape head loading resistor (adjusts the 15kHz level - i.e. the damping of the tape head resonance). If you have something different, we can make further guesses but we'd need to know what your Seduction circuit is and the equalization error values in the range 1kHz to 15kHz. To get the loading resistor matched to the tape head, you might look at the circuit values in the original built-in preamp. Heads vary widely in their optimum loading!
Doc B should be back online on Monday; he has the most experience with these issues and may have more to offer.